Short answer
Good starting problems include the Monty Hall problem (switching wins 2 out of 3 times), the birthday problem (23 people gives about a 50.7% chance that two share a birthday), the most likely sum of two dice (7), and Bertrand’s box (a 2 in 3 chance). Each is explained below.
Monty Hall: switch or stay?
There are three doors. One hides a car and two hide goats. You pick a door. The host, who knows where the car is, opens a different door to show a goat. Should you switch?
Switching wins 2 times in 3. Staying wins 1 time in 3. Many people think the choice is 50/50 once a door is open, but the host’s knowledge changes the odds. To check, play 30 rounds with three cups and a coin, and record the results.
The birthday problem
With 23 people in a room, there’s about a 50.7% chance that two of them share a birthday. With 70 people, the chance is about 99.9%. The question is about any pair in the room, not a match for you.
If you want a 50% chance that someone shares your specific birthday, you need about 253 people.
The most likely two-dice sum
The answer is 7. There are 36 equally likely outcomes, and six of them add to 7, so the chance is 6 in 36. A sum of 2 needs two 1s, so its chance is 1 in 36. Even though there are 11 possible sums, they are not equally likely. See dice math games for a classroom version.
Does the wording change the answer?
Yes. Consider two children:
- “At least one is a boy.” Both children are boys in 1 out of 3 cases.
- “The older child is a boy.” The chance that both are boys is 1 out of 2.
Small changes to the question change the answer, so read carefully.
Bertrand’s box and a gambler’s question
Bertrand’s box has three boxes: one with two gold coins, one with two silver coins, and one with a gold and a silver coin. Pick a box at random, and draw one coin. It’s gold. The chance the other coin is also gold is 2 out of 3, not 1 out of 2.
In the 1650s, a gambler named Chevalier de Méré posed questions to the mathematician Blaise Pascal. Two of them still make good puzzles. The chance of at least one 6 in four rolls of one die is about 51.8%. The chance of at least one double six in 24 rolls of two dice is about 49.1%. Their exchange with Pascal helped launch the study of probability.
Waiting times
Waiting-time puzzles surprise many students:
- The expected number of rolls to see a 6 is 6.
- The expected number of coin flips to get heads is 2.
- The expected number of flips to see HH (two heads in a row) is 6. The expected number to see HT is 4.
- The expected number of rolls to see all six faces of a die is about 14.7.
Penney’s game
Choose any three-flip sequence, such as HHT. Your opponent then picks a different three-flip sequence. For any sequence you choose first, your opponent can pick one that wins more often. For example, THH beats HHT about 3 times in 4.
Other puzzles to explore
- Buffon’s needle. If the needle is as long as the spacing between the lines, the chance it crosses a line is 2/π, about 0.637.
- The secretary problem. Skip the first 37% of candidates, then choose the next one better than all you’ve seen. This works about 37% of the time.
- Efron’s dice. Four special dice where each die beats the next one in a cycle with a chance of 2/3.
Common misconceptions
- Monty Hall is 50/50. It isn’t, because the host’s choice gives information.
- The birthday problem is about matching you. It’s about any pair in the group.
- Past flips change the next flip. They don’t. A coin has no memory.
- Equally possible outcomes are equally likely. Two dice have 11 sums, but they’re not equally likely.
Try it in class
Ask students to predict first, then test. Play Monty Hall with three cups, poll the class on birthdays, or tally two-dice sums over 50 rolls. Comparing predictions with results makes the reasoning stick. For easier experiments, try probability games for kids. For classroom games aimed at older students, see educational games for middle school students and educational games for high school students.