Classroom Games

How to set up a mystery game for kids?

How to set up a mystery game for kids: pick a theme, plan clues backwards, test-run it, and choose the right length and clue types for each age group.

On this page
  1. How to set up a mystery game for kids
  2. Step 1: Pick a kid-friendly theme
  3. Step 2: Decide the solution first
  4. Step 3: Plan the clues backwards
  5. Step 4: Write the intro and place the clues
  6. Age bands
  7. Lock boxes and hints
  8. Teams and the reveal
  9. Common mistakes
  10. Keep it safe

How to set up a mystery game for kids

Set up a mystery game in six steps. Pick a theme, decide the solution, plan the clues backwards from it, write a short story intro, place the clues, and test-run the whole chain before the game. The test-run is the step people most often skip, and it catches many problems early.

Step 1: Pick a kid-friendly theme

Good themes for children include a missing pet, a stolen treat, a lost treasure map, or a sabotaged birthday cake. For younger children, keep the story gentle. Murder or scary themes aren’t needed for a good mystery.

Step 2: Decide the solution first

Decide what happened, who was involved, and where the final clue leads. Keep it simple. A clear answer makes the rest of the planning easier.

Step 3: Plan the clues backwards

Start from the solution and work back to the first clue. Each clue should do one of two things: eliminate at least one suspect, or point to the next location. Add one or two red herrings only for older children, because they can confuse younger players.

Step 4: Write the intro and place the clues

Write a short story that explains the mystery and gives each player a role. Clue types can include:

  • ciphers, such as a simple A=1 code or a pigpen cipher
  • riddles
  • puzzle pieces
  • invisible ink revealed with a UV light
  • fingerprints

For children under about eight, hide clues in plain view. Clues hidden too well can stall the game.

Age bands

  • Ages 4-7: a treasure-hunt style game with picture clues, four to six clues, and 15-20 minutes.
  • Ages 8-12: a whodunit with three to six suspects, written alibis, six to ten clues, and 30-60 minutes.

Role-play murder mystery party kits are often rated for ages 8-12 and up. Check the kit’s rating before you buy it. For other games for a party, see unique party game ideas.

Lock boxes and hints

Use three- or four-digit locks, and make each puzzle answer give one digit of the code. Keep a hint plan. An adult “detective chief” can give hints at set times, so no group gets stuck for long.

Teams and the reveal

Teams of three to six kids work well. Larger groups can split into teams. Finish with a reveal where the kids explain their reasoning. This is the moment that shows what they learned.

Common mistakes

  • Clues that are too hard. This is a common problem, and it’s more frequent than clues that are too easy.
  • Scary or grown-up themes for young children.
  • Clues hidden too well for children under eight.
  • Skipping the test-run, which can leave a broken clue chain.

Keep it safe

Keep clues out of off-limits areas such as kitchens, stairs and outside the house, and away from hazards.

For classroom formats and lock puzzles, see classroom mystery games. For clue hunts that cover a larger area, see classroom scavenger hunt games.

The complete guide to classroom games

Learning Games for the Classroom
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →